[1] 247Sports listed Milton as a five-star recruit early on until his commitment to Georgia, at which time they changed him to a four-star.

[3] Upon Milton's arrival to Georgia, he was able to earn significant playing time, early in games, even as a true freshman.

In addition, although he missed half of the season to injury, Milton was able to earn All American Freshman honors.

[6] In 2022, he ran for 592 yards and eight touchdowns before his season was cut short due to a groin injury.

[9][10] In the 2023 Orange Bowl, Milton rushed for 104 yards and two touchdowns on nine carries, being named the MVP of the game and helping lead Georgia to the largest margin of victory in any bowl game at the FBS level with a 63–3 rout of Florida State.