Variety reported that CEO George Cheeks was opposed to promoting her to oversee the news division, which ultimately led to her being released from her contract.

The report noted that Godwin had promoted "key players" at Good Morning America, and had worked to increase ABC News' presence in audio formats and specials.

CNN reported that staffers voiced concerns regarding declining ratings for Good Morning America, considered the network's flagship show.

In an internal email to ABC staff in February 2024, Godwin condemned remarks made by former president and 2024 presidential candidate Donald Trump.

Godwin described Trump's suggestion that his highly-publicized mug shot would assist his campaign among black voters as “as racist as they come.” In the email, which was reported by Semafor, Godwin stated:[15]"No matter one's politics, the fact that a person running for President of the United States made these remarks period — but also to a public crowd — and with so many black people present — and that they stand with him — is mind blowing.