Before the 1873 season, he was traded to the Philadelphia White Stockings, where he played 48 games at third base and one at shortstop.

Meyerle played the 1874 season with the Chicago White Stockings of the National Association.

After the Philadelphia club was expelled from the league following the 1876 season, Meyerle signed on with the Cincinnati Reds.

He played only 27 games for Cincinnati, and didn't return to the major leagues for the 1878 season.

After 6 years out of major league baseball, Meyerle appeared in three games for the Philadelphia Keystones in 1884.