[2] McClutchie attended Hastings Boys' High School, where he played First XV rugby alongside future Hawke's Bay teammates Folau Fakatava, Devan Flanders, Danny Toala and Kianu Kereru-Symes.
[10] McClutchie made his Magpies debut on 22 September 2018 against North Harbour, starting instead of the regular fly-half, Tiaan Falcon, who had suffered an injury in the previous game.
[6] During the 2019 Super Rugby season, McClutchie was briefly called into the Highlanders squad as injury cover[11] and he also represented the Hurricanes at U20 level.
In November 2019, McClutchie signed with NTT DoCoMo Red Hurricanes Osaka for the 2020 Top League season.
On 20 October 2021, Moana Pasifika announced that the new franchise had signed McClutchie for the 2022 Super Rugby Pacific season.
On 8 December 2023, San Diego Legion announced the signing of McClutchie ahead of the 2024 Major League Rugby season.