In November 2019, LMU hired its first ever African American Athletics Director in Jasher Cox.

The men's and women's basketball, baseball, tennis, golf, cross-country and soccer teams have all made appearances in their respective national tournaments over the years.

The men's soccer team reached the NCAA Division II Championship Match in 2007, losing to Franklin Pierce College 1–0.

In 2016, the men's basketball team reached the NCAA Division II National Championship game, losing 90–81 to Augustana University.

In 2019, the Men’s Golf Team reached the NCAA Division II National Championship game, losing to Lynn University 3–2.