In her first Grand Slam event of the season, the 2012 Curlers Corner Autumn Gold Curling Classic, her team lost to Sherry Middaugh in the final.

In the second Grand Slam event of the season, the 2012 Manitoba Lotteries Women's Curling Classic, Homan's rink once again lost in the final, this time to Stefanie Lawton.

The win earned Weagle and her team the right to represent Canada at the 2013 World Women's Curling Championship in Riga, Latvia.

Until this point, Muirhead's rink had Homan's number, having also defeated her team in the semi-finals of the 2013 Curlers Corner Autumn Gold Curling Classic.

Homan's success over the last couple of seasons qualified her team for an automatic entry at the 2013 Canadian Olympic Curling Trials.

Homan's 2014 Scotties win earned her team a berth at the 2014 Ford World Women's Curling Championship in Saint John, New Brunswick.

The team had a better event than the previous worlds, as they only lost one round robin game to finish first place heading into the playoffs.

The team defeated Switzerland's Binia Feltscher in the 1 vs. 2 Page playoff game but were unable to beat them again when they faced each other in the final match.

The Homan rink ended the season with a loss in the final of the 2014 Players' Championship against the Olympic gold medalist Jennifer Jones.

The match marked the last game for second Alison Kreviazuk on the team, as she moved to Sweden to be with her boyfriend Fredrik Lindberg, who plays for Niklas Edin.

The team nearly missed the playoffs but won their final round-robin game against Tracy Horgan to finish the round robin in 4th place with a 7–4 record.

That season, the team would win one World Curling Tour event, the Pomeroy Inn & Suites Prairie Showdown held in March.

They began the season with a win in the Stu Sells Oakville Tankard, followed by a loss in the first Slam, the 2015 GSOC Tour Challenge against Switzerland's Silvana Tirinzoni.

In playdown play, the rink struggled in the round robin of the 2017 Ontario Scotties Tournament of Hearts, losing two games, and finishing second behind Jacqueline Harrison.

However, they won both their playoff matches, including defeating Harrison in the final, qualifying the team to represent Ontario at that year's Scotties.

At the 2017 world championship in Beijing, Homan's rink became only the third in tournament history to go unbeaten in round-robin play, joining fellow Canadian Colleen Jones from 2003 and Sweden's Anette Norberg from 2005.

Weagle and her team won the 2017 Canadian Olympic Curling Trials in her hometown of Ottawa, defeating previously unbeaten Chelsea Carey.

The following month, Homan won her third Grand Slam of the season, the 2019 Meridian Canadian Open, defeating Silvana Tirinzoni in the final.

A "number of curlers" at the event voted for her to win the tournament's sportsmanship award to protest the fact that the team had two members (Homan and Courtney) living in Alberta (teams are only allowed one "import" player from out of province, however, Homan maintains a residence in Ontario and is exempted from requirements as she is a full-time student at the University of Alberta).

[18] At the 2019 Players' Championship, the team struggled and ended up missing the playoffs after posting a 2-3 round robin record and losing the tie-breaker to Satsuki Fujisawa.

[19] Team Homan would win the first spot in the 2021 Canadian Olympic Curling Trials by defeating Tracy Fleury in the final of the 2019 Canada Cup.

At the 2020 Scotties Tournament of Hearts, they would win their second straight silver medal, losing the final this year to Manitoba's Kerri Einarson.

[21] Weagle played for the team when they won their lone event of the abbreviated 2020–21 season at the 2020 Stu Sells Oakville Tankard.

[23] A pregnant Dawn McEwen opted to stay at home, allowing Weagle to be the full-time lead on the team.

[24] At the 2021 Hearts, the team finished with a 9–3 record, putting them in a third place tiebreaker match against Alberta, skipped by Laura Walker.

The pair lost in the quarterfinals of the 2023 Canadian Mixed Doubles Curling Championship to Jennifer Jones and Brent Laing.

At the 2024 Canadian Mixed Doubles Curling Championship, she and Epping lost in the qualification playoff game to Nancy Martin and Steve Laycock.

Weagle and Epping qualified for the 2025 Canadian Mixed Doubles Curling Olympic Trials, where they finished third, losing 8-6 in the semifinals to Rachel Homan and Brendan Bottcher.

Weagle formerly worked for the Department of Canadian Heritage in Hull, Quebec as a communications advisor for Sport Canada.

[8] Her sister is curler Julia Weagle, her mother is author Brenda Chapman, and her father's name is Ted.