For every sport except football, the champion is determined using a postseason tournament or meet.
The most recent departures from American Conference women's lacrosse are affiliate members Cincinnati and Florida.
†: No longer members of the conference [2] The American dropped women's rowing after the 2023–24 school year.
[14] Villanova competed as an affiliate member in rowing from 2013 to 2015 before leaving for the Colonial Athletic Association (now known as the Coastal Athletic Association) and San Diego State competed as an affiliate member in rowing from 2015 to 2021 but discontinued its program because of financial difficulties caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.
SMU left for the Atlantic Coast Conference in 2024, leading The American to drop the sport.
[16] Charlotte, FAU, FIU and UAB joined the conference in 2022–23 as affiliate members for men's soccer.
[19][5] †: No longer members of the conference [2] The American dropped men's swimming & diving after the 2022–23 season.
Of the conference's 13 members in 2024–25, only Florida Atlantic offers men's swimming and diving.
[17] †: No longer members of the conference [2] Every school in The American apart from East Carolina and North Texas offers men's tennis; though East Carolina offered the sport until 2020 when it was dropped due to budget concerns brought on by the COVID-19.
[a][25] †: No longer members of the conference [2] Men's indoor track & field is sponsored by seven AAC schools: Cincinnati, East Carolina, Houston, Memphis, South Florida, Tulsa, and Wichita State.
*- Does not include vacated championships †- No longer a member of the AAC ‡- Affiliate member Laboratory schools: South Greenville Elementary School · Wahl-Coates Elementary School Former campuses: Future teams: Discontinued teams: Department of Defense Research Centers: Air Force Agency for Modeling and Simulation • Army Simulation and Training Technology Center • Naval Air Warfare Center Training Systems Division