The Division I First-Team All-Americans are the best eleven Division I U.S. college soccer players as selected by United Soccer Coaches.
From 1970 to 1983 the NCSAA only named defenders and forwards in addition to one goalkeeper.
* – repeat selection Beginning with the 1983 season, the NSCAA began naming midfielders in addition to forwards and defenders.
* – repeat selection Scholar Player of the Year in bold