Olson-Johns continued to compete in Alberta Women's Provincial Championships but did not see success until 2005, when she played third for skip Cathy King.

They won the Alberta championship and went on to the 2005 Scott Tournament of Hearts, where they finished the round robin at 6–5, and lost the first of two tie breakers to Ontario's Jenn Hanna.

However two months after this decision, it was announced that Olson-Johns would remain on the team, and lead Jennifer Sadleir would be replaced by Shannon Aleksic, following off-ice issues.

The team lost their first two games in the triple knockout event before winning three straight sudden death matches to qualify for the playoffs.

There, Alberta finished the round robin in second place with a 9–2 record, behind Team Manitoba, skipped by Jennifer Jones.

They won just one tour event (the 2015 HDF Insurance Shoot-Out), though they still made the playoffs in five of the six slams of the season, including making it to the finals of the 2015 Masters, where they lost to Homan.

[17][18] In the 2016–17 season, the Sweeting rink made the playoffs in five of the six slams, including winning the 2016 Tour Challenge and losing in the final of the 2017 Players' Championship.

[20] The team again lost in the finals of the 2017 Alberta Scotties Tournament of Hearts, this time losing to Shannon Kleibrink.

[25] For the 2018–19 season, Olson-Johns joined a new team skipped by Laura Walker with Cathy Overton-Clapham at third and Laine Peters at lead.

She did however get to play in the 2019 Champions Cup as second for Jennifer Jones, replacing Jocelyn Peterman who was competing at the 2019 World Mixed Doubles Curling Championship.