Lost Sirens drew mostly positive reviews, and it sold 4,678 copies in its first week in the United Kingdom.

In a Brazilian interview to promote the reunited band's appearance in São Paulo, Gilbert acknowledged issues with former member Hook, and stated there was "a lot going on behind the scenes on the copyright" delaying the album.

[4] The Independent's Andy Gill claimed that New Order's ninth outing "actually bests its parent album [Waiting for the Sirens' Call]".

[8] Metro stated the album "offers few classics but will still delight fans of the band with its feelgood sound".

[9] All tracks are written by Bernard Sumner, Peter Hook, Stephen Morris and Phil CunninghamCredits adapted from the liner notes of Lost Sirens.