The cast featured Emma Williams as Jenny, Michael Xavier as Oliver Barrett IV and Peter Polycarpou as Phil.

[2][3] Love Story transferred to the Duchess Theatre in the West End, officially opening on 6 December 2010 following previews from 27 November.

[8] The Walnut Street Theatre in Philadelphia presented the first American production of Love Story, as the first show in its 204th season, in September and October 2012 starring Alexandra Silber and Will Reynolds.

[9] The show had a limited run at the Edinburgh Fringe Festival at the Paradise in Augustine's Theatre in August 2013, starring Eloise Hare and Will Arundell.

Bolton Octagon, Greater Manchester presented Love Story as their closing show for their 2013/2014 run, in June to July 2014.

The reviewer of the Chichester Festival Theatre production wrote in indielondon.co.uk: "Stephen Clark has adapted the story into a succession of short scenes which, under Rachel Kavanaugh’s adept direction, follow on cohesively and coherently resulting in a believable and very poignant evening.

[T]he two principals, Oliver (Michael Xavier) and Jenny (Emma Williams)...give superb and utterly sincere performances.

"[13] Chichester Festival Theatre production review: "Howard Goodall and Stephen Clark have created a terrific new musical...The show finished to a chorus of heavy sniffles, superseded by hearty applause, which I take to mean a West End transfer should be given".

The framing epitaph is lovely writing, too.... Rachel Kavanaugh’s austere production on an all-white design by Peter McKintosh – whose three Corinthian pillars somehow conjure Pearl and Dean as readily as pearly gates – transfers well from the Minerva in Chichester....

This is a high-calibre chamber musical, all right, with a top skill factor in both writing and onstage musicianship (piano, guitar and string quintet); then just when it’s nearly enough, it plummets into bathos and easily resistible, tear-jerking manipulation.