Lucky Shoe is the only album by American alternative rock combo September '67.

Editors at AllMusic rated this album 3 out of 5 stars, with critic JT Griffith writing this album "will appeal less to [fellow Virginia act Dave Mathews Band] than fans of the Blake Babies, Sheryl Crow, Shelby Lynne, Cracker folk, and roots rock who will find Lucky Shoe an inspired (and largely undiscovered) gem".

[1] Industry magazine Billboard included a review that called this album one that "deserves consideration at college, triple-A, and modern rock outlets".

[2] In CMJ New Music Monthly, Scott Burke wrote that songwriter Shannon Worrell "reveals her truths slowly, taking her time to warm up to you, in measured tones", resulting in music that is "more than sweetly catchy".

[3] A 2021 retrospective in Perfect Sound Forever by Kurt Wildermuth called this "an album to remember" for being "lovingly crafted yet unstuffy pop-rock with articulate lyrics, delicious melodies, copious hooks, velvety vocals, and textures you can feel-sort of synaesthetically, as though someone just ran a finger down your back" with "recording [that] is so eerily physical, you want to trace the instrumental lines in the air".