She attended a developmental camp at the Karolyi Ranch where she earned the opportunity to compete at an elite qualifier.

[5] In March, O'Keefe competed at International Gymnix in Canada where she placed first in the all-around and finished top three on every event.

[10] She along with silver medalist Emma Malabuyo were selected to represent the USA at the 2017 International Junior Gymnastics Competition the following month in Japan.

[11] There O'Keefe won gold in the all-around and on beam and silver on floor, vault, and uneven bars.

[13] In her senior international debut, O'Keefe finished third with a score of 54.365, behind fellow American Morgan Hurd and Mai Murakami of Japan.

[16] After the meet she announced that she received early admission to the University of Utah and would be competing with their gymnastics program in the 2019–2020 season.

[18] O'Keefe made her NCAA debut in a meet against the Kentucky Wildcats where she competed on vault, uneven bars, and balance beam to help Utah win 196.425 to 195.350.

[28] During the team finals O'Keefe recorded the highest balance beam and uneven bars scores of the day and helped Utah place third.

[30] On January 29, in a meet against Stanford, O'Keefe earned her second career perfect ten on the balance beam.

[34] O'Keefe spent the majority of the regular season only competing on uneven bars, balance beam, and floor exercise.

[36] At the Pac-12 Championships O'Keefe led Utah to their third consecutive title and individually placed second in the all-around behind Jade Carey.

[37] In the post season O'Keefe earned her fourth perfect ten on balance beam while competing at the UCLA regional semifinal.

[38] At the NCAA team finals O'Keefe helped Utah place third for the third consecutive year and also earned her sixth perfect ten of the season on balance beam.