[3] In November, they signed with Run for Cover Records where they released a three-song digital EP entitled, Dahlia,[4] which was produced by Jesse Cannon.

Then-drummer Justin Collier replaced Wildrick on guitar and Mike Hrycenko (who was also in The Front Page) joined on drums.

Prior to releasing the album, the band will put out another compilation LP on Run for Cover entitled The Human Highlight Reel, that features Dahlia, Noise from Upstairs, Real Talk B-Sides, a "Promise Ring" cover and two brand new songs as well as a new 7 entitled The Absolute Worst on Rise on February 22, 2011.

[12] It was confirmed in July 2011 that the band was added to the opening act of the Pop Punks Not Dead Tour this fall headlined by New Found Glory.

In December 2011, Man Overboard acted as direct support for emo band The Early November on several of their reunion shows in the Eastern United States.

For the first half of 2012, Man Overboard will be touring the United States and Europe, with many different bands, including Trapped Under Ice, Daytrader, The Story So Far, Save Your Breath, and Handguns.

Drummer Mike Hrycenko did not join Man Overboard for their performance at the Pop Punk the Vote Tour.

This announcement followed the notion that Man Overboard, commonly recognised as "particularly frequent" with releasing music for their fans, had been relatively quiet for the past year.

[13] The next song entitled "Open Season" was released on April 9, featuring Geoff Rickly of post-hardcore band Thursday.

[14] The band would then release a music video for the next song off the album "Where I Left You" on April 24 through Rise Records's YouTube channel.

Heart Attack received generally positive reviews by critics, as well as opening up at #46 on the Billboard Top 200 with over 8,100 copies sold in its first week,[15] becoming the band's highest charted album to date.

On January 20, 2014, Man Overboard announced that they would be direct support for All Time Low on the "A Love Like Tour" in the United States, along with Handguns.

The day after, on May 11, 2015, the band released three tracks (Borderline, Splinter, and Now That you're Home) from the album with music videos on their YouTube channel.

The tour took place in late fall 2018, visited New York, Philadelphia, and Cambridge, and offered support from Seahaven.