[2][3] Creighton began his career in the youth team at Kidderminster Harriers, before spending a number of years moving between non-league, amateur clubs in the Midlands including Moor Green, Paget Rangers and Halesowen Town.

In the 2011/2012 season Creighton again proved to be influential in the Wrexham defence playing a part in breaking the club record for the most clean sheets in a row for the club; goalkeeper Joslain Mayebi gave credit to his regular defence (Nathaniel Knight-Percival, Neil Ashton and Chris Westwood).

[8] Creighton played in massive matches for the Dragons during the 2011/2012 season including the FA Cup 3rd Round draw away to Brighton & Hove Albion and in the replay back at The Racecourse which Wrexham lost on penalties.

[11] During his time off the pitch Creighton set up his own business, Raw Ink Tattoo studio in nearby Coedpoeth.

As well as his tattooing business Creighton also joined Welsh Premier League side Bala Town FC as a voluntary coach in January 2013.

Creighton's first start since August game in the FA Trophy against Gresley F.C., but after 20 minutes he picked up a recurring hamstring injury and was replaced by Kyle Parle.