[8] Although Docherty did not explain his reasoning for resigning, ahead of summer 2023 by-elections he was vocally critical of the Saskatchewan Party's record; he stated that "People are struggling" in reference to the party's tagline, "growth that works for everyone", stating further that "It hasn't worked for everyone in Coronation Park".
[9][10] New Democratic Party (NDP) candidate Noor Burki won the Coronation Park by-election to replace Docherty.
[10] In the lead-up to the 2024 general election, Docherty joined fellow former Saskatchewan Party MLA Glen Hart and former party staffer Ian Hanna in endorsing the NDP under leader Carla Beck, whose leadership qualities Docherty praised.
[11][12] Docherty stated that the Saskatchewan Party had "lost their way", alleging that Moe refused meetings to discuss issues.
[11] He cited the 2023 Parents' Bill of Rights as a policy designed to "subjugate people", and also related that during his time as Speaker, he felt "pressurized" to "rule in the government's favour on everything", adding on to allegations made by Weekes of being coerced in the role after taking over from Docherty.