He left the club in the following year to work as an assistant manager at San Jorge de Tucumán, and later moved to South Korea to coach Sancheong HS.

Back to Argentina in 2015, Cicotello was an assistant at Central Norte,[3] before joining San Telmo's youth sides in the following year.

[5] Cicotello left All Boys in May 2017, and joined Christián Lovrincevich's staff at Peruvian side Juan Aurich, as his assistant.

[12] Cicotello and Ruiz resigned from Arsenal on 8 May 2023, and he moved to Chile nine days later, after being named in charge of Unión La Calera.

[16] On 23 December 2024, Cicotello was announced as manager of Uruguayan club Montevideo City Torque for the upcoming season.