From the late 1960s to early 1980s, Jeremiah was a high school coach before she continued her experience at Cedarville College and the University of Dayton.
While at Indiana University between 1980 and 1986, her team reached the regional semifinals at the 1983 NCAA Division I women's basketball tournament.
After joining Cal State Fullerton in 1985, her team was in the second round of the 1991 NCAA Division I women's basketball tournament.
Between 1991 and 2003, Jeremiah stopped coaching to work as an women's administrator and associate athletic director with Fullerton.
With the NCAA Division I Women's Basketball Committee, she started a four-year tenure in 1998 and became their chairperson in 2000.
After resuming coaching in 2003, Jeremiah had a combined total of 440 wins and 348 losses in women's basketball upon ending her career in 2009.
[10] As a teacher throughout the late 1960s, Jeremiah started out at Fairborn Junior High School before going to the University of Dayton.
[11] During this time period, Jeremiah was a coach while at Fairborn and with a junior varsity team at Dayton.
[19] At the 1979 AIAW National Small College Basketball Championship, Jeremiah's team were runner-ups.
[31] During the 1983 NCAA Division I women's basketball tournament, her team reached the semifinals of the Mideast Regional.
[41] She was selected to help "find a replacement for men's basketball coach John Sneed" while working at Fullerton during April 1992.
[57][58] After Jeremiah started a four-year tenure on the NCAA Division I Women's Basketball Committee in 1998, she became the chairperson in 2000.
[62] During March 2015, she was chosen to be a sports commentator at the Women's Basketball Championship held by the Golden State Athletic Conference.
[63] While at Dayton, Jeremiah was the AIAW Coach of the Year for small colleges during the 1980 Margaret Wade Trophy Dinner.
[67] For Cal State Fullerton, she was the Big West Conference Women's Basketball Coach of the Year during 1988 and 1991.