The mascots go through a nomination process that ends with the executive committee selecting six finalist in each category to be placed on the ballot for consideration.

They must also impact both their sport and community, inspire their fans, and consistently give memorable and groundbreaking performances.

[citation needed] It was founded as an online-only hall, with an induction ceremony taking place each year in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

[3] On July 22, 2024, the hall of fame announced that the Whiting, Indiana museum will close on September 14 of this year.

In addition, the organization will continue online and are actively searching for a new location to host the museum.