[10] In round 23, he repeated the feat by kicking the winning field goal in the 79th minute at Penrith Stadium to beat the North Queensland Cowboys, 23–22.

[21] On 27 January, he was named by incoming coach Anthony Griffin as the new captain of the Penrith club for the 2016 NRL season.

[25] After showing good form in the early rounds, Moylan was leading the race for the fullback spot for New South Wales facing competition from Wests Tigers superstar James Tedesco and Lachlan Coote from the North Queensland Cowboys but eventually beating them to the starting number 1 jersey.

[26] On 1 June 2016, Moylan made his debut for New South Wales against Queensland, playing at fullback in the 4–6 loss at ANZ Stadium.

[27] After regaining the fullback spot for game 2, where the Blues lost 16-26 including the 2016 State of Origin series at Suncorp Stadium, Moylan was dropped from the team for James Tedesco.

[32] After Penrith's Round 5 clash against the Melbourne Storm, where they lost 28–6 at AAMI Park, Moylan alongside Waqa Blake and Peta Hiku were dropped to the Panthers NSW Cup team for 1 match after they breached the booze curfew by being out in the Melbourne nightlife into the early hours of the next morning.

On 9 November 2017, it was confirmed that Moylan was released from his contract with Penrith to join the Cronulla Sharks in a swap-deal with James Maloney, being signed on for four years.

[40] In round 1 of the 2018 NRL season, Moylan made his club debut for the Cronulla Sharks against the North Queensland Cowboys, starting at five-eighth in the 20–14 loss at 1300SMILES Stadium.

[41] Moylan made a total of 24 appearances for Cronulla in his first season with his new side as the club reached the preliminary final before losing to Melbourne 22–6.

[42] In round 3, Moylan suffered a hamstring injury in Cronulla's 42–16 win over North Queensland ruling him out for six weeks.

[44] On 1 March, Moylan was ruled out of the first 4–6 weeks of the 2020 NRL season after suffering a calf injury in pre-season training.

[45] Moylan played 15 games for Cronulla in the 2021 NRL season which saw the club narrowly miss the finals by finishing 9th on the table.