Rogelstad went on to play one year of college baseball, where he hit .279 for the Southeastern Louisiana University Lions.
[citation needed] Rogelstad played for Team Canada at the 2005 Baseball World Cup in the Netherlands.
He played the 2007 season for the Class A Advanced Potomac Nationals, where his .302 batting average ranked him third among all Carolina League hitters.
He hit .360 with 9 runs and 8 RBIs in 7 games while serving as Canada's primary third baseman during the 2008 Olympic Qualification Tournament.
Rogelstad had his best game yet of the season on December 7, netting 4 goals and 2 assists in a 7-6 winning effort over the Lancaster Chiefs.