Together they face the trials of growing up, love, sex and high school, but these two best pals are in for the adventure of a lifetime.

[4][5] It was produced by StarKid Productions[1][2][7][8] and the University of Michigan's Basement Arts,[5][7] and was directed by Matt Lang.

[4][5][6] The musical stars an ensemble cast featuring Joey Richter as a fictionalized version of himself,[4] Joe Walker as his dick named Dick,[4] Jaime Lyn Beatty as Sally, and Devin Lytle as Sally's vagina, Miss Cooter.

[2][4][7][8] Joey Richter wakes up one morning and begins talking to his best friend, his penis, Dick, about their non-existent sex life.

This includes talking about Joey's crush on a particularly attractive and popular girl named Vanessa.

Dick then tries to talk Joey into "introducing" him to Vanessa and talks him into "taking life by the balls," in order to win Vanessa's heart and get Joey to lose his virginity ("Me and My Dick").

While waiting to walk to school with Joey, Sally begins talking to her vagina, Miss Cooter, who is equally upset with their sexual situation.

Tiffany then talks Vanessa into hooking up with a loser to get back at Rick, in this case, Joey ("Ready to Go").

In the midst of the hug, Dick and Miss Cooter meet and fall in love ("I've Seen You Around Here Before").

Tiffany arrives at Vanessa's to give her a box of "tools" in case her study date with Joey turns into an "epic fail," including handcuffs, beer, and condoms.

Vanessa then tries several different ways to show Joey she's interested in him, but Dick tells him to play it cool, so he shrugs off her advances.

Because of this, Joey and Dick experience erectile dysfunction, which leads Vanessa to throw them out of her house.

Dick becomes lost while searching for Miss Cooter, but he meets two abandoned penises, Big T and Weenie.

Miss Cooter manages to convince the Council that love between genitalia does exist, and they agree to help her.

The group meets up with Miss Cooter and the Old Snatch, who told Joey not to tell anyone of the world of walking, talking genitalia, which he accepts.

At this point, Miss Cooter prepares to leave, but the Old Snatch reveals that she isn't going back to Tiffany, as she plans to see the world.

Joey tells Sally he loves her, and the two decide to culminate their feelings by finally having sex.

Meanwhile, Vanessa is envious of their new-found love, but gets back together with Rick, who says the rumors of him cheating on her were false.

Holmes and Matt Lang as part of the University of Michigan's Basement Arts 24 Hour Theater festival, where teams of writers, directors, and actors are challenged to create a show in a day.

After the success of Starkid's A Very Potter Musical, the pair collaborated with Lang's brother Nick and Darren Criss to expand the show into a full two-act musical, to serve as Starkid's second production.

[10] All of the songs featured on stage are present on the recording, except for the short reprises of "Me and My Dick" performed by Joey Richter and The Old Snatch in Act II.