The school offers a select few sports, including basketball, cross country, soccer, track and field, and volleyball.

[9] The Miami Norland basketball and football teams have enjoyed success in recent years by winning a number of FHSAA championships.

Miami Norland has produced a number of professional athletes, especially National Football League (NFL) players.

Most notably, the seven-time Pro Bowler and Super Bowl champion wide receiver Antonio Brown (2006), graduated from the school.

Aside from Brown, only three other graduates have won a Super Bowl: Darrin Smith (1988), Mike McKenzie (1994), and Carlton Davis (2015).

Graduates from the 2000s include: Kareem Brown (2001), Antwan Barnes (2003), Richard Gordon (2005), Travell Dixon (2009), and Tourek Williams (2009).

Gil Patterson (1974) played in Major League Baseball (MLB) and Bruce Savage (1978) was capped for the United States men's national soccer team.

Non-athletes include: the longest coma patient, Edwarda O'Bara (did not graduate), educator Ronni Sanlo (1969), murderer-rapist Daniel Conahan (1973), and judge Ian Richards (1993).