Mickey and friends' traditions of togetherness are threatened when they get separated after shopping for gifts, and have to get back to Hot Dog Hills in time for Christmas.

[21] Ben Breitbart of LaughingPlace.com described Mickey and Minnie Wish Upon a Christmas as a "strong holiday special," noting that it captures the nostalgia and joy of the season.

He found its straightforward storytelling and return of beloved characters, like Cuckoo Loca, charming and accessible for newcomers.

[24] Stephanie Snyde of Common Sense Media rated it three out of five stars, noting its positive messages and role models, emphasizing the importance of friends and family as demonstrated by the characters, and complimented the songs and humor throughout the special.

[27] In September 2023, Disney Publishing Worldwide released a book inspired by the television special titled Mickey and Minnie Wish Upon a Christmas.