Out of 14 contestants, Milk placed ninth overall, losing a lip-sync to Trinity K. Bonet in the sixth episode.

[16] In 2017, Milk appeared as Madonna in a video promoting the skincare range, dressing in several of her iconic costumes.

[17] He performed at the Bryant Park Figure-Skating Rink for the Guys On Ice event as charity for the Ali Forney Center.

[19] He then released his first solo single, "Touch the Fashion, Change Your Life",[20] which he performed live on the first episode of All Stars 3 in 2017.

He was in an open relationship with James B. Whiteside,[23] principal dancer with American Ballet Theatre, for 12 years.