[4] Writing for the Associated Press, Jim Pollock compares this release to "a visit to an unfamiliar city", as "it feels anarchic and unstructured until the listener has some time to acclimate to its rules and norms".

[3] Siobhán Kane calls this release "delicate, trippy, grungy and wildly unpredictable" and rated it 4 out of 5 stars in The Irish Times.

[8] The Skinny's Joe Creely considers this release "an album where brevity belies what an enlivening and broad world it contains" and gave it 4 out of 5 stars.

[9] In The Spill Magazine, Joseph Mastel rated it a 7 out of 10, writing that the lyrics are weak and cautioning that "mainstream music listeners and audiences will likely not enjoy Miracle-Level that much", but he finds that "it is good to try new things" as the band does on this album.

[10] In Under the Radar, Kyle Kersey rates Miracle-Level an 8 out of 10, summing up his review that it is "a celebration of the human spirit, one that offers optimism and wonder in the face of pessimism and hopelessness.