During a meeting at the Pawtucket Brewery, Peter feels unwell as a result of eating the raw cookie dough and a taco he found in the parking lot, and he soils himself trying to get to the restroom while evading various people.
Depressed and exhausted following that incident, Peter comes home from work to find his friends and family gathered in the living room.
After the service, Thelma's closest friend, Evelyn, approaches Peter, and the two connect after she tells him about her husband, Walter, dying some time ago.
The next day, he visits his mother's grave, where he sees Evelyn, who apologizes to Peter and explains that she had taken advantage of him since he was the first man to pay any real attention since her husband died.
Brian attempts to console him by seeking out several religions and showing their beliefs on the afterlife like visiting a Jewish synagogue, the Quahog Buddhists Temple, and a Catholic church.
Brian, despite the fact he went to Heaven and has also met Jesus Christ in person multiple times, believes that nothing happens after someone dies, reflecting his atheist views.