[8] All Music Italia's Fabio Fiume gave "Mon amour" a score of 6+/10, pointing out how "it is less memorable, less hypnotic" compared to the previous single "Bellissima".

Fiume also found that the singer's voice had been "exploited differently; ... the virtuosities are in fact reduced to the bone", adding the dynamic of the song is also "tense, without drops in intensity".

[9] Gabriele Fazio of Agenzia Giornalistica Italia was also not particularly impressed by the song, believing that "nothing remotely artistic is perceived" as it is dedicated to "a disinterested and superficial audience" becoming "just another hit, one of those that does not want to communicate anything".

[15] "Mon amour" became the first song by Annalisa to reach the top of the singles chart, making her the first Italian female solo artist to achieve this since Anna in 2020 with "Bando".

[19] At RTL's Power Hits Estate 2023, "Mon amour" was awarded the SIAE prize for the most performed song of the summer at Italian musical events.