Their first release was a split album in 2005, with "Treasure Chest At The End Of The Rainbow" also a Luxembourg-based band, in which Sacha Hanlet was also active.

At this time, the band consisted of David Schmit (guitarist of Eternal Tango), Luciano Lippis and the two founding members.

This split album was licensed by the Canadian record label New Romance for Kids, for Canada, United States and Japan.

Thereafter, Mutiny on the Bounty toured through Europe and shared the stage with bands like: Battles, And So I Watch You From Afar, 65 Days of Static, Coheed and Cambria, These Arms Are Snakes, Akimbo, Russian Circles, Portugal.

After nearly two years of preparation, they finally went in the studio to record their debut album Danger Mouth with Philippe Matgé one of the best sound engineers throughout Luxembourg.

Other international concerts followed, inter alia a gig at the South by Southwest (SXSW) festival in Austin Texas.

The band sent Bayles a link with a few of their songs, and after a meeting in the context of their performance in Austin they had convinced him to record their new album.

Mutiny on the Bounty were supported by the Luxembourgish bands Heartbeat Parade and Mount Stealth.