The following is a list of the top team performances during the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division I college soccer NCAA Division I Men's Soccer Championship as of May 2021 with teams listed by number of championships, second-place finishes, and semifinal finishes.
Third place matches were only held between 1974 and 1979.
[1] All schools are listed by their current athletic brand names, which do not always match the names under which they competed in a specific tournament.
Schools in Italics no longer compete in Division I.