[3] Construction of the theater featuring a stained glass skylight, brass chandeliers and a curved staircase leading to the balcony started in 1879.

In 1905, following her debut in San Francisco, Luisa Tetrazzini performed on stage and in the same year, Jack London read from his works.

The structure was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1973; however, it was not until 1985 that a non-profit group was set up to restore the theatre.

[8] The upstairs theatre has seating for an audience of 500, modern lighting and sound system with an orchestra pit large enough for 40 musicians.

The venue now hosts several headline entertainment acts every month including plays, musical performances and dance.

Peter Williams left City Winery in May 2014 to move back to booking Yoshi's San Francisco, which was sold to new owners.