From 1946 to 1950, Nazareth teams played exclusively as members of the Class D level North Atlantic League, qualifying for the 1946 playoffs and finishing in last place in both of their final two seasons.
[1] A printed postcard of the 1907 Nazareth team identified them as the "pennant winners" of the Blue Mountain League.
The Bloomingdale Troopers, Carbondale Pioneers, Mahanoy City Bluebirds, Newburgh Hummingbirds, Nyack Rockies, Peekskill Highlanders and Stroudsburg Poconos joined Nazareth in beginning league play on May 8, 1946.
[4][5][6][7] The Nazareth Cement Dusters qualified for the 1946 playoffs in their first season of play in the North Atlantic League.
The Cement Dusters ended the 1946 season with a 78–40 record, placing second in the standings, playing under manager Stan Benjamin.
[21][22][5][23][7] In their final season of play, the Nazareth Barons again finished last in the North Atlantic League Standings.