[10][11][12] Prior to realignment that took effect in the fall of 2010, New Milford was a member of the Bergen County Scholastic League (BCSL) in the Olympic Division.

[19] The football team was awarded the sectional championship by the New Jersey State Interscholastic Athletic Association in 1972 (as co-champion).

[21] The 1985 team won the North I Group I state sectional title with a 10-7 win in overtime against Hasbrouck Heights High School in the championship game.

[24] In 2004, the baseball team won the program's first Group I state championship, defeating New Providence High School by a score of 2–0 in the tournament final.

[28] Pitcher PJ Saporito was named 1st team all-league, all-county and all-state while compiling a 12–0 record and 0.53 ERA, and was selected as the North Jersey Player of the Year.

[29] The team repeated as league and as North I, Group I sectional champions in 2005 with a 6–5 win over Glen Rock High School.

[32] On June 23, 2007, a group of 55 music students was selected to participate in the second episode of the reality show Schooled, after which they were surprised with a private concert by The All-American Rejects and given backpacks filled with OfficeMax merchandise.