Originally formed by former players from Hakoah Vienna, including Béla Guttmann and Rudolph Nickolsburger, they initially played in the Eastern Soccer League in the fall of 1928.

[4] Kurt Lamm coached the team for 14 seasons, including their three consecutive American Soccer League Championships (1955/56 - 1957/58).

[5] Ron Glickman decided to try and rebuild the Hakoah club in the New York City suburb of Teaneck, New Jersey.

[8] Hakoah Bergen County joined the North Jersey Soccer League Premier West Division for the 2011/12 season where they finished in fourth place.

[9] In August 2012, the club announced that they would re-brand and continue the legacy of New York Hakoah.