Newburgh Taylor-mades

Charles Fisher served as manager, as Newburg finished 25.0 games behind the first place Kingston Colonials.

[11][12] Newburgh finished with a 39–81 record under managers Charles Fisher, John Green and Fred Taylor.

Newburgh ended the 1905 regular season with a record of 60–54, playing under returning manager Fred Taylor and Henry Ramsey.

On September 9, 1906, Newburgh was 16.0 games behind the first place Paterson Invaders when the Hudson River League ceased play for the season.

The Hudson River league was down to four remaining teams, after having the Kingston and Paterson franchises fold in early June.

The Newburg Hillies were managed by Jim Connor and had a 15–11 record, and stood 1.5 games behind the first place Poughkeepsie Colts when the league folded.

The Newburgh Dutchmen became members of the six–team Class D level New York-New Jersey League, placing sixth in the 1913 standings.

Long Branch (65–29) was followed by the Poughkeepsie Honey Bugs (48–49), Kingston Colonials (45–46), Middletown Middies (42–51), Danbury Hatters (43–55) and Newburgh Dutchmen (41–54) in the final league standings.

Poughkeepsie finished with a record of 65–31, followed by the Newark Cubans/Long Branch Cubans (59–32), Middletown Middies (47–45), Danbury Hatters (49–48), Perth Amboy Pacers (44–49), Newburgh Hill Climbers (40–48), Paterson Silk Citys (32–54) and Bloomfield-Long Branch Cubans/Asbury Park Sea Urchins (30–59) in the final standings.