It is historically the most successful side in the history of Shinty, having won the Camanachd Cup a record 34 times.

[3] Since then, the club has won the Camanachd Cup 34 times – a record unmatched by any other team in the game.

Two of the greatest names in shinty history, goalkeeper Hugh Chisholm and David "Tarzan" Ritchie jointly hold the Newtonmore club record of twelve Camanachd Cup winners medals each.

Many clubs throughout Scotland have long and friendly rivalries with Newtonmore – notably, Kyles Athletic who they met frequently in Camanachd Cup Finals in the 1970s.

However, from 2010 Newtonmore have won the Premier Division title and numerous cups at both first and reserve team level.

2010 saw them go into the last game of the season against Fort William with the chance of winning the league by only needing to avoid defeat.

Newtonmore did clinch the double with revenge over Kyles in the Camanachd Cup final, their second title in three years.