In the spring of 2011, Judge Mykola Yashchenko of the Kyiv Court of Appeals ordered further investigation into the incident, ruling the prosecution had not properly established a cause of death.

The Shevchenkivskyi chief of police Petro Miroshnychenko announced: "We know that Indylo fell three times.

"[citation needed] On June 2, Ukraine Parliamentary Commissioner for Human Rights Nina Karpachova stated that Indylo's death was a murder and police will try to "hush up" the case.

Journalist Dmytro Gnap announced that Indylo was most likely pushed hard, he hit the wall and became unconscious because the right half of his brain was injured.

Journalist Olena Bilozerska and human rights activist Tetyana Yablonska also believed that Indylo was tortured.