The club managed to reach the tier-one Bezirksliga Württemberg in 1932 and played at this level for one season, before the league was dissolved.

In 1965 they re-emerged in the Amateurliga Nordwürttemberg (III), capturing the division title, and then taking part in the promotion round playoff for the Regionaliga Süd (II).

However, they were unable to advance and spent most of the next ten years in the Amateurliga before slipping to lower-tier competition in 1975.

In 1972 Normannia enjoyed a solid run in the national amateur championship, going as far as the semi-finals before being put out by FSV Frankfurt.

FC played in the Oberliga Baden-Württemberg (IV) as a lower table side until 2012 when it was relegated again.