A reissue, entitled Not So Silent Night – The Cozy Edition, featuring three news songs, was released in November 2023.

[3] In her review for laut.de, Kerstin Kratochwill wrote that "the perfectly polished pop" on Not So Silent Night "shines like an over-decorated Christmas tree.

"[4] WDR 2 critic Oliver Rustemeyer found that Not So Silent Night is "also a typical Christmas album, but it not only sounds contemplative, but also wild and at least partly rocky.

"[7] Enwie Kej from Der Vinylist found that "the flow and impulsiveness of the first three songs is lost on the rest of the album.

"[6] mix1 noted that "the new songs vary in sound from a Motown feel to messages of peace and a countdown to the turn of the year.