It features Katy Perry as a guest star, playing Honey, the gullible character that the episode is named after.
Robin explains that it began when Zoey offered to hook up Ted with her cousin (Katy Perry).
Ted decides to let Barney leave with Honey, later confessing to Robin that he has fallen in love with Zoey.
In the present, Marshall receives a call from Barney, who tells him that something strange had happened after hooking up with Honey.
As Marshall explains the situation to Marcus and Judy, Zoey confronts Ted, demanding to know the real reason that he does not want to be friends.
Club put the episode at A−, saying the story of Zoey and Ted's first kiss and the multiple phone conversations were gimmicks to keep the audience hooked.