Owners John & Pam Gallo sold the Raging Tide franchise, which became the Bristol Blues.

The All-Americans reached the playoffs in the team's inaugural season but fell 2 games to 1 to the then-Rhode Island Gulls.

During the 2010 NECBL regular season, the All-Americans played two home games in Nashua, New Hampshire and one at The Ball Park in Old Orchard Beach.

On Sept. 22, 2010, the Old Orchard Beach Town Council accepted a letter of intent from the All-Americans to place a franchise at The Ball Park, a move that the NECBL had approved.

The Raging Tide finished the inaugural season at The Ball Park with a record of 9-33, last in the Eastern Division.