Former Victorian Premier League and Brunswick Juventus midfielder Luciano Fioravanti[9] was signed as inaugural Senior Men's head coach, and the club was successfully granted entry into the independent Amateur Soccer Federation Victoria (ASFV) for the 2002 season.

The club's inaugural season was a success having fielded three teams, in which all were competitive that saw the senior squad earn their first premiership and cup tournament victory.

The club's first-ever match was played at Xavier College against Arlaadi United in what would be a dominant 9–0 victory with a squad average age of 20.

The match finished in a 5–1 emphatic victory with future team of the decade forward Anthony De Luca scoring four to secure promotion.

2008 saw both the seniors and reserves come close to first place with Middle Park being consistent in their dominant season, with thirds finishing mid table in their respective division.

Success was finally brought to Hays Paddock in 2009 with both the seniors and reserves finish strongly in both divisions with new nemesis Middle Park coming close in both leagues.

2010 saw the reserves team for the first time in the club's history win back-to-back championships, with the seniors and thirds both finishing mid table respectively.

The club announced its team of the decade featuring Ennis La Torre, Paul Marazita, Nicholas Butler, Matthew Clyne, Michael Sette, Liam Flynn, Michael Fragale, Andrew Vittadello, Gianni Bramante, Adrian Ubaldi, Anthony De Luca, D Clyne, Daniel Prossimo, Joseph Robilotta, Marco Stella, and Thomas Voss.

This list consisted of Brown, Hainsworth, Michael Esnault, Ashe, Antoni, Andrew Kavanagh, Callahan, Peter Kozle, Juan De La Pava, Giorgio Perelli, Liam Flynn, Balaton, Ficici, Longo, Melvin, Tamanas, and Toomey.

The men's senior squad would start the era slowly by finishing mid table of the Victorian State League Division 5 (tier seven) eastern conference for 2013.

With a major reshuffling of the metro system occurring again in early 2014, the thirds were demoted back to tier thirteen, then renamed to its current name of 'Metropolitan League Six' but this time in the south-eastern conference.

It was these results that drove the veterans team to win the eleventh tier championship, known as the Metropolitan League four in the north-western conference after three close attempts.

With both teams winning their last two games, the veterans' four-point lead was dealt a blow in round sixteen against University of Melbourne SC after a 0–1 loss at Princes Park.

[22] One on one, Old Xaverians drew[23] and lost[24] to Hoppers during the regular season but with luck on the veteran's side, it was the match drawn thanks to University that made the difference, resulting in promotion for the second time in three years.

The two teams of the club were both invited to participate in the trial of the new Video assistant referee for the A-League at Docklands Stadium midway through the season.

The thirds for 2017 were rezoned to the north-western conference from the south-east of the Metropolitan League five following due to location clashes of other promoted and relegated teams.

The men's veterans squad would continue its successful period following on from 2013 by winning back-to-back championships and promotions for the first time ever in the club's history.

The second loss considerably threatened first place chances as at that point of the season it had become clear that the top three would be battled between Old Xaverians, RMIT and Moreland.

The 2017 era started with a sense of optimism for the women's department following the establishment of the reserve team in meeting the demands of multiple player signups.

A strong campaign would see the reserves be serious championship and promotion contenders, but it would be bad luck loss in round seventeen[35] that would make the team finish second, two points behind Old Trinity Grammarians.

The senior men's team would finish eighth out of twelve, which could've so easily been fifth place with unlucky second half losses to Brunswick Zebras,[39] Heidelberg Eagles,[40] Plenty Valley Lions,[41][42] and Northern Falcons.

The reserves match saw the Climate of Melbourne at its finest with the culturally popular term "four seasons in one day" physically becoming reality before and during the game.

Like in the first half, it would be La Trobe who would equalize almost immediately with an unmarked long shot from outside the eighteen yard box leveling the scores at 4–4.

The men's squad commenced their 2020 campaign with the senior team losing 1–2 in the first round of the 2020 FFA Cup against La Trobe University at David Barro Stadium.

The first round of the league season for both the senior and reserve squads was to be against Northern Falcons on 21 March 2020, however Football Victoria suspended and then eventually cancelled all soccer competitions and related events due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

[49] During the second Metropolitan Melbourne lockdown, inaugural Senior Men's head coach Luciano Fioravanti passed away on 4 September 2020 aged eighty-three.

After winning their inaugural game at the school grounds, the club temporarily moved to H A Smith Reserve in Hawthorn, sharing with Old Scotch.

Upon leaving the Balwyn North park at the conclusion of the 2004 Provisional League Three season, the site had seen Old Xaverians celebrate two championships and two promotions.

Home Away Alternative Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.