British magazine Music Week rated the song three out of five, adding, "Gap Band-style funk meets the hookline of Pull Up To The Bumper on this feel-good single, providing an ideal basis for Coolio's slick rapping.
He concluded, "A bit of a throwaway compared to the mighty Gangsta's Paradise, (...) with Coolio's rhymes surprisingiy trite and childish but no less commercial for it.
Coolio opens the newspaper and reads "Today you will find the Love of your Life, BUT BEWARE, she will NOT REVEAL herself to you.
Coolio then goes about his day doing laundry, grocery shopping, and using an elevator, all while attempting to find the love of his life.
After no success, he resorts to spiking a girl's drink with a love potion, serving it to her at a restaurant while posing as a waiter.