Eventually more space was needed and OYC built a new clubhouse in 1919, the facility now known as the McCrobie Civic Center and for a time as the Naval Militia Building, a historic clubhouse building located at Oswego in Oswego County, New York.

It was built in two phases; the center section was begun in 1914 and completed in 1919 as the yacht club.

The original section is a one-story Arts and Crafts style building with a walk out basement in the rear and Colonial Revival features.

It was designed by noted Rochester architect Claude Fayette Bragdon (1866-1946).

[1] In 2005, OYC moved to its present location at 19 Lake St, at the Oswego International Marina.