Other musicians who contributed to the recording include Bryan Loss (drums) and Matthew Brauss (bass guitar).

Commercially, the song peaked at number three on the US Billboard Hot 100 and topped the charts of Australia, Canada, Ireland, and the United Kingdom.

[3] Rashaun Hall of Billboard wrote that "Over and Over" possesses "real emotion" and praised Tim McGraw's "moving" vocals.

[18] Across continental Europe, the single entered the top 10 in Austria,[19] the Czech Republic,[20] Denmark,[21] Germany,[22] Hungary,[23] Romania,[24] and Switzerland,[25] achieving a peak of number two on the Eurochart Hot 100.

[32] The settings feature similar scenes of them encountering fans at gas stations, traveling, and making visits to the airport, all the while both preoccupied with their respective significant others.

In the end, they both depart on separate but comparable private jets, possibly to meet up with the women they have been singing about throughout the video.