Lurie describes the local tree frogs he hears in their natural habitat and their musical coordination.

[2] The series' soundtrack features music by Lurie, who was a founding member of the Lounge Lizards and the creator of Marvin Pontiac.

Robert Lloyd of Los Angeles Times wrote "Painting with John represents HBO at its most worthwhile: arty and unpredictable.

"[16] Robert Ito of New York Times described the show as "a meditative and often joyful blend of painting and personal storytelling.

The website's critical consensus states, "A celebration of art and life through the eyes of a delightful curmudgeon, Painting with John is a surprising, intimate feat of TV joy.".