[3] 1987 proved to be a bitter-sweet year for the Club after struggling early for numbers, the arrival of Gavin Ward saw the influx of a number of new players and by season's end, Panton Hill not only made the finals but under Captain/Coach, John Stanley recorded a memorable come-from-behind win against Hurstbridge in the first semi final.

Although beaten in the preliminary final against Coolaroo the good finish to the season looked set to be the catalyst of better things to come.

With Dennis Kerr as Senior Coach, the Club struggled again to attract players due to travel and the highly competitive nature of the League.

While wins were few and far between in the early stages, the Club quickly gained a reputation for their "never say die" attitude and fierce determination.

After the success of 1992 better things were expected but once again the Club went on a roller coaster ride and continued to struggle to recruit quality players.

The club defeated perennial Diamond Valley power Greensborough in one of the biggest upsets in football history.

The club bowed out the next week after George Le Broq medallist and man about town William Box withdrew due to injury, the team shattered about the loss of their beloved roaming backman.

Key forward Jonathon "Joffa" Byron, who earlier in the season had topped 100 goals, struggled to influence the club's big day.

Somehow, Watsonia booted four goals in quick succession and had a 5-point lead with 3 minutes remaining and a classic choke loomed for the minor premiers.

However, a kick to the forward pocket found Jarrod McGough who slotted an outstanding set shot goal from 40m on a tight angle.