Despite being tipped by some as relegation candidates at the start of the year, Pascoe Vale finished in 6th place in 2015, qualifying for the finals series.

Facing South Melbourne at Lakeside Stadium, Pascoe Vale conceded two late goals in extra time to go down 3–2.

Pascoe Vale finished the 2016 season in 7th place, with Van't Schip scored 9 goals and taking out the club's Golden Boot award.

Van't Schip was the top scorer for the third season running, this time with 15 goals, the fourth highest tally in the league.

[5] From January 2019, Pascoe Vale player Hakeem al-Araibi, a political dissident from Bahrain,[6] was being held in Thailand pending deportation to Bahrain.This attracted much media attention and a campaign for his quick and safe return was spearheaded by the club, with support from Craig Foster.

His brother Michael Ferrante, along with Luca Santili and Davey Van’t Schip also departed the club, while David Chick was named as the new head coach.

In the lead-up to the 2024 season, Pascoe Vale signed Dandenong Thunder’s renowned 2012 treble-winning captain Shane Rexhepi as their new head coach, while also beginning a multi-million dollar redevelopment of their home ground, Hosken Reserve.