All told, Peebles Rovers played 86 Scottish Football League matches, winning 28, drawing 15 and losing 43.

Peebles Rovers themselves were active long before the Third Division, being formed in 1888 and have played in the Scottish Cup proper over twenty times.

After that they took some serious hammerings, losing 10–0 away to St Mirren in 1959, 6–1 at home against Ayr United the next year, and then a 15–1 slaughter away to Hibernian in 1961.

Joe Baker scored nine that day and his brother Gerry grabbed four in the earlier debacle at Love Street.

Their greatest moment in the Qualifying Cup (South) came in the 1953–54 competition, when they defeated Shawfield Amateurs 6–1, Burntisland Shipyard 7–0, Selkirk 4–2 (all at home) and Coldstream 4–1 after a 1–1 draw away to reach the final.

In the 1966–67, Rovers joined the junior grade of football and entered a period of decline, until they rejoined the senior ranks in the East of Scotland League in 1980–81.

Wilson was joined in December 2020 by Colin Macdonald, a local businessman who accepted the role of Club Chairman.

Following a poor start to the 2022/23 season, Wilson joined Vale of Leithen, leaving the way clear for Ger Rossi to return as manager for a second spell after a successful period with the club a few years earlier.