[2] Men's basketball was part of the Orange Belt Christian Conference (OBCC) of the NCCAA from the 1980s until the early-1990s, winning the in-season tournament multiple times.
[5] They would play at the 2,000-seat Hall Field House until 1993 when they moved to the much larger and more spacious Arlin R. Horton Sports Center.
Men's soccer is PCC's newest sport, returning to Pensacola Christian in the fall of 2016 for the first time since the 1980s.
[15] Men's soccer has won the NCCAA Division II national championship three times, most recently in 2023.
Their 2021 appearance marked the first time the Lady Eagles advanced past the pool stage of the tournament before they were eliminated in the semifinal round by Johnson University (TN).
[18] Former "heritage" sports at Pensacola Christian College include baseball and men's wrestling.
Pensacola Christian and Alabama Christian (now Faulkner University) played an extremely unconventional triple-header on April 10, 1982, in which the Eagles lost all three games and were outscored 30–6, allowing a total of twenty stolen bases in games consisting of five, seven, and six innings, respectively.
[30] 1 All-American 3 All-Americans Jim Hazewinkel NCCAA Coach of the Year 5 All-Americans Outstanding Wrestler Award Recipient Jim Hazewinkel NCCAA Coach of the Year 4 All-Americans Jim Hazewinkel NCCAA Coach of the Year PCC Invitational Champions[31] 7 All-Americans Jim Hazewinkel NCCAA Coach of the Year PCC Invitational Champions[32] 4 All-Americans PCC Invitational Champions[33] 4 All-Americans 1 At-Large All-American Ben Peterson Christian Sportsmanship Award Recipient Jim Hazewinkel NCCAA Coach of the Year[b] NCWA Southeastern Conference Tournament Champions NCWA Southeastern Conference Tournament Champions Jim Hazewinkel NCWA Coach of the Year[34] NCWA Southeastern Conference Tournament Champions NCWA Southeastern Conference Tournament Champions Jim Hazewinkel NCWA Coach of the Year[35] NCWA Southeast Conference Tournament Champions Sources:[27][28] The Arlin R. Horton Sports Center is the home arena for the basketball and volleyball programs.